1. Home
  2. Sports
  3. Football

Favre a Backup? Rodgers in No-Win Situation

By , About.com Guide

Jul 14 2008
Reports surfaced over the weekend indicating that Brett Favre would be welcomed back by the Green Bay Packers, but only as the backup to Aaron Rodgers, who has been groomed all offseason for the starting role.

Can you imagine that? The future Hall of Famer carrying a clipboard for a guy who has never started an NFL game?

Of course, anyone with any sense knows that situation would never work.

First of all, the Packers aren't likely to pay $10 million for a backup QB. Even more of a problem, however, would be the pressure it would place on Rodgers' shoulders. With every interception... heck, with every overthrow or one-hopper he delivers, the chants for Favre would grow. With every loss, the second-guessing by the media would increase.

Regardless, though, of whether Favre ends up on the Packers roster or the roster of another team, as long as he is in an NFL uniform he's going to make life tough on Rodgers. If Favre does eventually land with another team in a starting role, there will be constant comparisons between the two. So unless Rogers clearly outplays Favre, there will be a significant faction among Packers fans that will resent the team's decision to not welcome back a guy who has been the face of the franchise for more than a decade-and-a-half. And much of that resentment may be directed at Rodgers.

However Favre returns, assuming he does, it seems like a no-win situation for Rogers to me. He either loses his starting job or constantly battles the ghost of a legend. Anything short of looking like a legend-in-the-making himself would make it very tough to escape Favre's shadow.

Explore Football

About.com Special Features

Holiday Central

What to eat, where to go, fun things to do and how to save money on the perfect gifts. More >

Introduction to Pilates

Learning Pilates fundamentals can help you get the most out of your exercise regime. More >

  1. Home
  2. Sports
  3. Football

©2009 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.